Defending Alaska's Students: Our View on the Homeschool Allotment Ruling

The recent Superior Court decision to strike down Alaska's correspondence school reimbursements has sent ripples across our state, affecting thousands of families who rely on these funds to tailor their children's education. These funds have traditionally supported a range of educational choices, enabling families to design learning experiences that perfectly match their needs and aspirations.

At North Star Tutors and Frontier Tutoring, we are more than just bystanders; we are passionate advocates for the educational journey of each student we support. Today, we want to share our heartfelt concerns as well as our commitment to navigating these changes together. We stand at a pivotal moment—one that calls for thoughtful reflection and decisive action to ensure that our educational systems continue to serve the diverse needs of all Alaskans effectively and fairly.

Why This Ruling Hits Home

Education is deeply personal and profoundly impactful. The flexibility afforded by these now-unconstitutional statutes allowed homeschooled families to craft educational experiences that were as unique as each child—whether that was a home science kit for a budding biologist, books for a young literature lover, or even unique courses catering to unconventional talents. Families have been able to choose educational resources that align perfectly with their children's needs and interests, fostering a critical sense of engagement and enthusiasm for learning within their homeschooled students.

The Superior Court's decision, grounded in a legitimate concern over the separation of public funds from private education, unfortunately, casts a long shadow of uncertainty over these personalized learning paths. This sudden removal of funding not only jeopardizes the educational continuity for many students who used these funds appropriately but also places a sudden financial strain on families who had planned their educational year around having these funds available. Moreover, this ruling impacts a broad swath of our community, including independent educators and other service providers who had depended on these allotments for their livelihood.

We also must acknowledge, however, that the allotment program was intended to enhance educational access and flexibility for homeschoolers without diverting public money toward private or religious schooling. Even as an occasional recipient of allotment funds for our tutoring services, we support the Alaska Constitution's provision designed to prevent the misuse of public funds, as they should benefit a broad public educational system accessible to all. Turning Alaska's correspondence school reimbursements into what essentially functions as a school voucher program poses significant risks and undermines the original goal of supporting equitable public education. An example of the pitfalls of voucher programs in general can be found in Arizona, where 80% of the applicants for a universal voucher initiative enacted in 2022 were already not in the public school system, turning what was intended as an educational support tool into, as state superintendent of public instruction Kathy Hoffman put it, a "taxpayer-funded coupon for the wealthy." Rather than diversifying educational opportunities for students in need, the program largely subsidized private education for families who could already afford it.

Here in Alaska, the intent behind the correspondence school program and its associated allotments was the noble goal of making homeschooling more accessible and affordable for all students, but the execution has drifted from its original purpose. And though we agree that public funds should not be used to subsidize private education directly, we also need to make sure that we don't throw the baby out with the bathwater. What we need is a recalibration -- new legislation that will help us to restore these funds to their rightful use: enriching the educational opportunities for homeschooled students and making homeschooling a viable option for families from all backgrounds without encroaching on public resources designated for public schooling.

Our Call to Action

This pivotal moment is a wake-up call for all of us who value educational freedom and equity. Here at North Star Tutors and Frontier Tutoring, we are advocating for lawmakers to create new legislation that not only respects our constitution but also empowers families to educate their children in rich and varied ways. We need clear, robust guidelines that prevent misuse while preserving the essential tools that many homeschooling families rely on to provide comprehensive education.

Fairness for Educational Providers

The sudden freeze on allotments has put a strain on our community's independent educational providers—tutors, artists, musicians, and more—who have delivered services under the old system. These community members have contributed significantly to student education, expecting fair and legal dealings. It is essential, irrespective of future decisions regarding the use of allotments, that school districts and correspondence programs who have enacted payment freezes work urgently with the Legislature and the State to find a way to compensate these providers for services already rendered. This is not just a matter of contractual obligation but of moral responsibility to support those who contribute to our educational ecosystem.

Make Your Voice Heard

Now more than ever, your voice matters. We encourage all affected families and advocates of flexible education to engage with this issue actively. While it remains unknown whether a stay will be issued on the Superior Court's ruling or whether the Alaska Supreme Court will take up the issue, it is never too early to reach out to your state representatives and senators to share how this ruling affects you and what you would like to see in upcoming legislation. Your personal stories and experiences are powerful and can significantly influence the direction of new laws. You can find your legislators' contact information by going to the Alaska Legislature website and entering your address in the bottom-right corner of the page in the "Who Represents Me?" tool. 

Looking Ahead

We will remain steadfast in our dedication to the educational success of your children and committed to championing solutions that serve the best interests of our entire community. Together, we can advocate for a diverse, flexible, and equitable educational system that truly supports the needs of every Alaskan student, while at the same time ensuring homeschooling remains a viable, sustainable, and well-supported choice for families.

Let's stand united for our students, for their futures, and for the integrity of education in Alaska. We are here for you.